The performance and price point puts the Icarus right in the mix with other top approach shoes.
BEST FOR: Long approaches
Butora has become one of the biggest players in the U.S. climbing shoe market over the past several years, but the Icarus is the first one of their approach shoes we’ve taken for a spin. At 14.5 ounces, the Icarus is a sturdy, solid shoe—not one of those minimalist things that you’re likely to roll your ankle in scampering up a class 3 trail—but not unduly heavy. Wrapped in Butora’s proprietary NEO Fuse rubber, the Icarus provides all-day support and still climbs pretty well on low-end technical rock.
I took the Icarus out for several laps in the Flatirons above Boulder—my go to testing site for approach shoes—and found it was just as much at home smearing on the low-angle sandstone of the First Flatiron as it was boulder hopping to reach the base of the soaring slab. The rubber on the sole has several different patterns of tread, including a completely flat and un-patterned area under the toe that allows you to climb proper technical terrain. The back of the shoe is quite stiff and angles in slightly towards your Achilles’ tendon, keeping your foot snugly in place. I did find it dug into the back of my ankle a bit uncomfortably after a long day out, but I expect this to get better as it continues to soften up from use.
The Icarus’ upper is suede leather, reminiscent of most of the other big shoe manufacturers’ workhorse approach shoes. The inside of the shoe has a nice amount of cushion—not so much that it feels like your foot is wedged into a marshmallow, but enough that you can take it out on long hikes to reach the base of the climb (or just to hike for that matter!).
Butora recommends going a half size up from your street shoe with the Icarus. If you’re likely to take this shoe out on fifth-class terrain, true street-shoe size is probably better, but if you’re using them as hikers, the recommendation is spot on.
The performance and price point puts the Icarus right in the mix with other top approach shoes, so if you’re looking to try a new boot, this is definitely worth a look.
Rock and Ice vigorously tests all gear it reviews for either 50 days or 50 pitches. This is a time-consuming process and limits the amount of new equipment we can present to our readers. Every year hundreds of new products hit store shelves, and most of these aren’t reviewed due to our stringent selection and review process. To better keep you more up to date on what is new, we present First Look. Gear in First Look has not always been field tested, but is gear we think you’d like to know about as soon as it is available. Some of the gear will be reviewed using our 50 days/50 pitches criteria, in future print and online editions of Rock and Ice. We have opted to use affiliate links in our gear reviews. Every time you buy something after clicking on links in our gear articles you’re helping support our magazine.
Five Ten Five Tennie
MSRP: $125 BEST FOR: Scrambles and around town The original Five Tennie—dreamed up by Five Ten founder Charles Cole back in the ‘80s—was the first real, modern approach shoe: a hybrid running-hiking-climbing shoe … Continue reading “Five Ten Five Tennie”
Garmont Sticky Cloud Approach Shoes
MSRP: $159.95 BEST FOR: Approach and hiking WEIGHT: 1 lbs 12 oz (per pair, men’s size 8.5) These shoes were delivered to the Big Stone Publishing offices, where we produce Trail Runner and … Continue reading “Garmont Sticky Cloud Approach Shoes”