Trango Maxcam Review

The Maxcam is heralded as the first cam with an asymmetrical design (the inner cams are longer than the outer lobes) and floating axles.

By Duane Raleigh | December 7th, 2010

TRANGO_CAM.jpg
Trango Maxcam | $59.95 to $79.95 | Trango.com

The Maxcam is heralded as the first cam with an asymmetrical design (the inner cams are longer than the outer lobes) and floating axles. In theory, the Maxcam’s evolutionary design beats the Camalot’s expansion range, and works better in irregular placements, where the unit’s independent suspension can adjust to radical variations such as flaring pin scars. For these reasons, the Maxcam has a lot of fans. It received an Editor’s Choice from another magazine and is lauded online, though mostly by people who have never used a Maxcam.

While we liked the Maxcam’s syringe trigger action and promising range, the units were seriously unstable in deep, parallel-sided cracks, such as desert splitters, where the units were free to pivot. When the Maxcam was able to pivot, its outer lobes tended to walk up and invert, losing contact with the rock—that is, with a few jiggles the cam could rattle right out of the crack. The problem was especially noticeable when the units were placed at or above 50 percent of their ranges, but the larger sizes tended to invert at just 40 percent of their ranges.

Cam inversion was not a problem in placements that pinned the cams, preventing the units from walking or pivoting. Placements of this type are common in granite, and could explain why some climbers have not had a problem with the new Trango units and prefer them over other cams. Maxcams also fared well in horizontal placements that let the stem swivel up and down, eliminating walking.

Some will contend that inversion caused by cam jostling or “walking” is a problem endemic to all cams that are placed above their mid-expansion points. True. All cams are more prone to inverting at the upper end of their ranges, generally around 75 percent, but can be as high as 90 percent. The fact that the Maxcam is unstable at midrange, however, sets it apart from all others. Trango itself notes in its Maxcam instructions that each unit “must be [placed] in the lower 1/2 of its expansion range,” a point that negates the benefit offered by the extended-range design.

The Maxcams were also tricky to place. When I inserted the cam at an angle to the crack or let the trigger spring from my fingers (rather than gradually, as you should do), the cams inverted. With practice and careful technique I could minimize, but not eliminate, placement error—a blind placement would be a crapshoot. Finally, the common technique of shoving a cam deeper into a placement or pushing it overhead can also invert the Maxcam. (Trango notes this and cautions against using the Maxcam this way.)

For all-around use, Maxcams offered no benefit over Camalots—they aren’t lighter, are up to 4 kN weaker, don’t save you any money, and, even if they did have a greater camming range (Trango overstates the range for four of its five Maxcam sizes), are only one of two cams I’ve ever used that could actually rattle out of a good placement.

 

Size Price Range (mm) Cam Ratio Weight (oz) Strength (kn) CE
Black Diamond Camalots
0.3 $59.50 13.8-23.4 1.69:1 2.5 8 yes
0.5 $59.50 19.6-33.5 1.7:1 3.4 12 yes
0.75 $59.50 25-41.2 1.64:1 4.2 14 yes
1 $62.50 30-52 1.73:1 4.8 14 yes
2 $62.50 37.4-64 1.71:1 5.4 14 yes
3 $68.50 51-87 1.7:1 7.2 14 yes
4 $78.50 71-114 1.6:1 9.8 14 yes
5 $98.50 87-148 1.7:1 13.5 14 yes
6 $109.50 114-195 1.71:1 19.8 14 yes
Metolius Supercam
Small $65.50 39.5-70.5 1.78:1 6.4 13.3 no
Omega Pacific
#1 $91.00 20-55 2.75:1 6.3 14 yes
#2 $98.25 25-64 2.56:1 7.3 14 yes
Trango MaxCams
0.5 $59.95 19-33 1.73:1 3.8 9 no
0.75 $59.95 23-41 1.78:1 4.3 10 no
1 $69.95 25-51 2:01 5.1 12 no
2 $69.95 33-65 1.96:1 6 12 no
3 $69.95 49-87 1.77:1 7.8 12 no

Leave a Reply

Notify of
avatar
wpDiscuz

Wild Country Helium Friends

Wild Country’s Helium Friends are a new and different take on the Friend. The first thing you might notice is the name. “Helium” replaces “Technical Friend,” and with a change like that you would expect these cams to be lighter.

read more

Camalot X4

Black Diamond’s X4s are a big addition to small protection. Even boiled down, their nuts and bolts are a mouthful: The six sizes protect from .33 to 1.62 inches, have four cam lobes and a narrow head.

read more

Black Diamond Offset Micro Stoppers

These tiny nuts are a compound of copper and iron machined to offset wedges and swaged with a patented technology that Black Diamond claims is strong, flexible and not prone to fraying. These are the next-generation RP.

read more