Should I clip Ice Screws with Screamers?

Screamers are break-apart quickdraws that absorb some of the energy in a fall, but will using one on an ice screw make it less likely to rip out?

By Rock and Ice | February 4th, 2011

Is it necessary to clip all ice screws with Screamers?

 Screamers, those load-absorbing, tear-apart sewn slings made by Yates, might help a marginal ice screw hold a fall, but so might divine intervention. A Yates Ice-Scream ($20) activates at roughly 440 pounds, and, according to Yates, reduces peak loading by 660 to 880 pounds. Over the past decade I have used Screamers and taken numerous live test falls, long and short, with a little to a lot of rope out, and have never generated a load as low as 440 pounds. This isn’t a hard-and-fast rule, but it is reasonable to assume that if you fall onto an Ice-Scream you will always activate it. Now, will the Ice-Scream prevent a screw from pulling? A screw in bad ice will likely rip regardless, while a screw properly placed in solid ice will probably hold regardless. Screamers hedge the bet in that gray zone of the unknown, and ice, ever changeable even on a good day, is the cup in which you shake the dice. Screamers can weight the dice in your favor. I own and use a couple of Screamers, but more for rock rather than ice pro for the simple reason that if the ice is bad I don’t stop and waste time and effort putting in screws, and if the ice is good, the screw probably will hold without a Screamer.

Leave a Reply

Notify of
avatar
wpDiscuz

Can Sleeping on Your Rope Cause Damage?

Entire generations of luckless alpinists have used ropes to level out ledges and insulate against the cold ground, ice and snow.

read more

Will Dog Urine Harm My Rope?

A buddy’s dog peed in the general direction of my new rope. I don’t think it was a direct hit per se, but collateral damage is a high possibility. Do I need a new rope or will a good scrubbing do the trick?

read more

What's the Point of Spotting Highball Boulder Problems?

When a person skyrockets off a problem from four times their height, does spotting expose numerous people to injury instead of just one?

read more